If I remember correctly, it's the 30th anniversary of the first broadcast of the original radio series of
The Hitch hikers' Guide to the Galaxy today. I believe there was a ZZ9 slouch in Islington to celebrate this. Me, I have been at work all day, and spent all morning running around fixing broken computers.
Now, I no longer think digital watches are a pretty neat idea, but I retain the ability to get inordinately excited by certain expensive small black bits of electronics. Odd, really. The novelty ought to have worn off by now.
So it is with considerable pleasure that I have spent much of this afternoon playing with the minute matt black metallic cuboid of a new Nokia E90, which the nice people at O2 have given me,
gratis, just for promising to stay with them for 18mth. They threw in unlimited free web access, too, which is nifty as it's a 3.5G phone and I can plug it into my laptop's USB port and use it as a mobile broadband connection.
(Which I've been doing all afternoon and it doesn't half nuke the battery.)
Vodafone couldn't be bothered to tell me when they came into stock and wanted me to pay £250 or so for one
on top of signing up for another 18mth. When I threatened to leave, they still wanted over £100 for the handset, and that's with no Net access thrown in, either.
Initial impressions:
- Very sleek, fairly fast, excellent mobile Web experience and copes with things like PDF and DOC pretty well too. Sluggish at desktopy-type stuff but it's all there. Flash, Java, whatever. I don't know how anyone lives with a Web-capable smart phone with a 320*240 screen: it's like a postage stamp. On the internal eight hundred and mumble by three hundred and mumble screen, the Web's actually quite usable and quick.
- Also, having online help in a complex smartphone is a good thing.
- MicroSD cards really are
stupidly small. Drop it in shagpile, never see it again. Or watch the cat swallow £60's worth of storage thinking it's a small cornflake.
- I am not sure that I need an Eee or a Nokia N800 any more with this thing. N800s seem to be getting very cheap on eBay, like £50-£100 or so, but this thing delivers most of the functionality and although it talks Wifi I don't need to find an access point. A lightweight subnotebook - like a
sub-£200 Thinkpad X30 - and one of these and you're sorted.
- If I can get my data onto it, my Psion 7Book has just been obsoleted, too, except as a mobile writing machine. And if I can get the folding Bluetooth keyboard I bought for my 7710 working with the E90, it might do well enough for that, too.
- The onboard software is functionally
very limited, but
after this, I expected that. I'm hoping I can supplement it with 3rd party extras to make it do what I need.
- There's about 2-3cm of fascia wasted on decorative trim or blank spots when they could have put 2mm or so gaps between the buttons, enhancing its usability, especially when operating by feel alone. This is amazingly daft. However, overall, the design's pretty good. The rocker button thing on the inside is meant for right-handers, but I can cope. I used to have a Qtek 9000 (
dougs lent me the old one he bought from
autopope and I went and got it nicked going to the Slimelight), AKA HTC Universal, AKA XDA Pro or something. Great spec, great functionality,
horrible design, and cursed with the affliction that is Windows Mobile. This thing, with Symbian 9 and S60 GUI, is a marvel of sleek elegance by comparison.
Summary: nice toy. Nice price. So far, we like. May do proper writeup once I've got to know it; watch this space for a link to the Inq. ;¬)
Oh yes. Concluding thought. This is the ultimate pre-iPhone smartphone. Bags of functionality, dozens and dozens of tiny buttons, two screens, insanely complex. Compare & contrast to the stripped-down elegance of Apple's offering. I'm a geek: I enjoy learning to use complex tech. It's fun for me. But I would not inflict an E90 on anyone who wasn't a hardcore geek, whereas I reckon my mum would do fine with an iPhone. Again,
Orlowski put it very well:
Steve Jobs' justifiably calls MultiTouch the biggest Apple innovation since the first Macintosh. Although hyperbole billows out of Jobs like smoke from an out-of-control dry ice machine, I think he's fully justified in being proud of the implementation. Not since the days of Psion have we seen such an example of "extreme engineering" in a consumer product - where the capabilities far outstrip the competition, in a product that costs less to manufacture. This is the reward for investing in great engineers - and ensuring they meet really strict goals.
The iPhone really is
years ahead of devices like the E90.
What amuses me so far is that everyone else in this biz has signally
totally failed to get the point of the iPhone. Look at toys like the Viewty. The clever thing about the iPhone is not that it's all touchscreen, that it's sleek and minimalist, that it's heavily multimedia-oriented. The clever things about the iPhone are:
- multitouch;
- that it runs a ported, cut-down version of a proper grown-up OS, not some allegedly "lightweight" thing meant for low-function low-power devices;
- multitouch;
- a honed-down, super-heavily user-focussed, very easy user interface, not a nightmare of options to twiddle;
- multitouch;
- an almost complete lack of options and ports and slots and things to play with. It has what it
needs and no more. You don't
need to change batteries; usually, you just replace the phone. Given enough memory, you don't
need to insert stupid tiny expansion cards;
- multitouch.
I like the iPhone. I didn't buy one, though. I want buttons to dial with; I want a keyboard to type on. I want to be able to use a Bluetooth keyboard. I want to be able to use it as a modem on my PC. I want Flash and Java. I want to be able to install my own apps. And I want it all for free. So I got an E90, and so far, I'm happy. But give me an iPhone Pro with number keys down the sides of the screen and a slide-out keyboard and the missing functionality added back in and I'd think about it. Offer me it for free and I'd take your arm off.
There are lessons here both for Apple and for everyone else.
Enough. Gone 7. Pub now.